Service Tax on CNG Outlets: Supreme Court Holds BPCL and HPCL Acted as Commission Agents of Mahanagar Gas, Liable for Business Auxiliary Service
In Commissioner of Service Tax v. BPCL, 2026 INSC 723, Mahanagar Gas Ltd. supplied CNG compressed by its own equipment at BPCL and HPCL petrol pumps in Mumbai and Thane, which sold it to vehicle owners at prices fixed by MGL and received a commission. CESTAT held the oil companies were buyers and resellers. Analysing the agreements, the Supreme Court found that MGL fixed the price, controlled supply, bore the risk and kept title, and that the oil companies earned commission, not trade discount. They were therefore MGL’s commission agents rendering business auxiliary service taxable under Section 65(19).
Key Takeaways
- Whether an arrangement is sale or agency depends on the agreement as a whole: price control, title, risk and nature of payment.
- Where the supplier fixes price, controls supply, retains ownership and pays commission, the outlet is an agent, not a buyer.
- Selling goods on behalf of a principal for commission is business auxiliary service under Section 65(19).
- A commission agent falls within Explanation (a) to the definition.
- K. Arumugam (lottery tickets) was distinguished, as no promotion of the client’s goods was involved there.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Commissioner of Service Tax, Mumbai v. M/s Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd., etc. (including Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd.) |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 723 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal Nos. 2471-2473 of 2015 |
| Bench | Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice N.V. Anjaria |
| Authored by | Justice N.V. Anjaria |
| Date of judgment | 20 July 2026 |
| Impugned order | CESTAT, West Zonal Bench, Mumbai common order dated 04.06.2014 |
| Law involved | Sections 65(19) and 65(105)(zzb), Finance Act, 1994; Section 35L, Central Excise Act, 1944; sale versus agency |
| Counsel who argued | Mr. Raghavendra P. Shankar, Additional Solicitor General, with Mr. Gurmeet Singh Makker, Advocate-on-Record, for the Revenue; Mr. M.H. Patil, Advocate, with M/s S. Narain & Co., Advocates-on-Record, for BPCL and HPCL |
| Result | Revenue appeals allowed; CESTAT order set aside; service tax demands restored |
Facts of the Case
MGL received natural gas from GAIL, compressed it with equipment it installed at outlets including BPCL and HPCL pumps, and paid excise duty on CNG. The oil companies sold CNG to vehicle users at MGL-fixed prices and received a margin.
The Revenue treated this as business auxiliary service and confirmed service tax by Orders-in-Original of 16 August 2012. CESTAT, Mumbai allowed the oil companies’ appeals on 4 June 2014, treating the transactions as sale and resale.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 16.08.2012Orders-in-Original confirm service tax.
- 04.06.2014CESTAT sets aside demands.
- 2015Revenue appeals filed.
- 20.07.2026Supreme Court restores demands.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Did BPCL and HPCL’s sale of MGL’s CNG at their outlets constitute business auxiliary service liable to service tax?
Arguments and Counsel
Revenue (Mr. Raghavendra P. Shankar, ASG)
The agreements showed MGL controlled price, supply and title, and paid commission; the oil companies were promoters and agents.
BPCL and HPCL (Mr. M.H. Patil)
They bought CNG from MGL and resold it, earning a trade margin; sale of goods is not a service.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Agreement clauses
MGL fixed prices, monitored supply, retained control of equipment and goods, and bore risk; the oil companies acted as facilitators.
2. Commission, not discount
The payment was commission for sales, an attribute of agency.
3. Title did not pass
Ownership remained with MGL until sale to consumers; the oil companies were recipients, not buyers.
4. Taxable
Their activity was business auxiliary service as commission agents.
Final Decision
Revenue appeals allowed. The CESTAT order was set aside and the Orders-in-Original of 16 August 2012 confirming service tax demands against BPCL and HPCL restored; the Revenue may enforce the demands as adjudicated.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| K. Arumugam v. Union of India, (2024) 10 SCC 733 | Distinguished: lottery tickets not goods |
| Benjamin’s Sale of Goods | Distinction between sale and agency |
Analysis and Practical Points
Fuel retailers and others selling a supplier’s product on commission should review service tax and GST positions. Under GST, similar agency arrangements may have consequences for valuation and supply classification.
- Retail outlets: Agreements with price control and commission indicate agency, attracting tax on services.
- Suppliers: Structure arrangements clearly as sale or agency and document title transfer.
- Tax advisers: Review pending service tax disputes on commission-based retail arrangements.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Supreme Court decide in CST v BPCL?
In 2026 INSC 723 it held BPCL and HPCL liable to service tax as commission agents of Mahanagar Gas for CNG sales.
Why was it agency and not sale?
MGL fixed prices, kept title and control and paid commission.
Which service category applied?
Business auxiliary service under Section 65(19) of the Finance Act, 1994.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
