Income-tax valuation provisions

Section 55A Income Tax Act: Reference to Valuation Officer

Section 55A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 dealt with a reference by the Assessing Officer to a Valuation Officer for determining the fair market value of a capital asset. From 1 April 2026, the corresponding current provision is Section 91 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, subject to the transition rules for earlier tax years and pending matters.

Current law update: The Income-tax Act, 2025 came into force on 1 April 2026 and repealed the Income-tax Act, 1961. However, the old Act continues to govern tax years beginning before 1 April 2026 and proceedings, rights, liabilities and other matters preserved by the repeal and savings provisions. Accordingly, Section 55A remains relevant to legacy years, while Section 91 of the 2025 Act is the operative provision for the new regime.

What is a reference to a Valuation Officer?

A valuation reference is a statutory mechanism that enables the Assessing Officer to obtain a departmental valuation of a capital asset where its fair market value is relevant for computing income under the capital gains provisions. The object is to place the valuation exercise before a Valuation Officer when the conditions laid down by the applicable income-tax law are satisfied.

Fair market value generally refers to the value that an asset would ordinarily fetch in an open market on the relevant date, subject to the specific definition, valuation rule and statutory context applicable to the transaction or computation.

A registered valuer and a departmental Valuation Officer are not the same. A taxpayer may rely on a valuation made by a registered valuer where the law permits, while the Assessing Officer may make a statutory reference to a Valuation Officer in the circumstances prescribed by the Act.

Current provision: Section 91 of the Income-tax Act, 2025

Section 91 permits the Assessing Officer, for ascertaining the fair market value of a capital asset for the relevant Chapter, to refer the valuation of that asset to a Valuation Officer. The section broadly carries forward the function previously performed by Section 55A of the 1961 Act, but the procedural cross-reference is now integrated with the valuation provisions of the 2025 Act.

Section 91 in simple terms

The Assessing Officer may seek a departmental valuation where the taxpayer's claimed value, including a value based on a registered valuer's estimate, falls within the statutory circumstances for a reference. Once a reference is made, specified procedural provisions of Section 269 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 apply with necessary modifications.

When can the Assessing Officer make a valuation reference?

SituationStatutory basis under Section 91
The value claimed by the assessee follows an estimate made by a registered valuer.A reference may be made if the Assessing Officer is of the opinion that the value claimed is at variance with the fair market value.
The case is not based on such a registered valuer's estimate.A reference may be made where the Assessing Officer considers that the fair market value exceeds the claimed value by more than the prescribed percentage or amount.
Nature of the asset or other relevant circumstances justify valuation.A reference may also be made where, having regard to the nature of the asset and other relevant circumstances, the Assessing Officer considers it necessary.

Important: Whether a particular valuation reference is valid depends on the law applicable to the relevant tax year, the statutory conditions, the reasons forming the Assessing Officer's opinion, and the facts of the case. The provision should not be read independently of the applicable valuation rules and related capital gains provisions.

Procedure after a reference to the Valuation Officer

Under Section 91(2) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, the specified provisions of Section 269(3) to Section 269(8) apply, with necessary modifications, to a reference under Section 91. These provisions regulate important parts of the valuation process, including inspection and information-gathering powers, opportunity to the assessee, the valuation report and the manner in which the Assessing Officer may use that report.

Section 269 is broader in its own assessment context and deals with estimation of the value, including fair market value, of an asset, property or investment. For a Section 91 reference, only the sub-sections expressly incorporated by Section 91(2) apply with the necessary modifications.

Section 55A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 for earlier years

For matters governed by the Income-tax Act, 1961, Section 55A authorised the Assessing Officer to refer the valuation of a capital asset to a Valuation Officer with a view to ascertaining its fair market value for the purposes of the relevant Chapter.

Where the assessee relied on a registered valuer

If the value claimed by the assessee was in accordance with an estimate made by a registered valuer, the Assessing Officer could make a reference where the officer was of the opinion that the claimed value was at variance with its fair market value.

Other cases

In other cases, Section 55A permitted a reference where the statutory threshold concerning the difference between fair market value and the value claimed was met, or where the nature of the asset and other relevant circumstances made a reference necessary.

The old provision also applied specified provisions of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957, with necessary modifications, to such references and adopted the meaning of "Valuation Officer" from that Act.

Which law applies after 1 April 2026?

Period or matterRelevant law
Tax Year 2026-27 and later tax yearsIncome-tax Act, 2025, including Section 91 where applicable.
Assessment Year 2026-27 and earlier yearsIncome-tax Act, 1961 continues to govern those earlier periods, subject to the repeal and savings provisions.
Pending assessment, appeal or other proceeding relating to an earlier yearThe transition and savings provisions preserve the operation of the earlier law as applicable to that matter.

Therefore, a page about "Section 55A" remains useful for historical and pending matters, but readers dealing with a current tax year should also examine Section 91 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 and the Income-tax Rules, 2026.

Practical points for taxpayers

  • Identify the tax year or assessment year first; this determines whether the 1961 Act or the 2025 Act governs the matter.
  • Keep the registered valuer's report, valuation date, basis of valuation and supporting documents available where a claimed value is based on expert valuation.
  • Read the valuation reference together with the capital gains provision under which fair market value is relevant.
  • Check the applicable rules for prescribed percentages, amounts, valuation methodology and procedure rather than relying on an old threshold quoted in a legacy article.
  • Where a departmental valuation is proposed or used, examine whether the statutory procedure and opportunity requirements applicable to the case have been followed.

Frequently asked questions

Is Section 55A still the current provision for new tax years?

No. The Income-tax Act, 2025 is in force from 1 April 2026. For the new regime, Section 91 is the corresponding provision dealing with reference to a Valuation Officer for fair market value of a capital asset. Section 55A remains relevant to periods and matters governed by the repealed 1961 Act.

Does a registered valuer's report prevent a departmental valuation?

No. Under the statutory conditions, the Assessing Officer may refer the asset to a Valuation Officer even where the taxpayer's claimed value follows a registered valuer's estimate, if the applicable condition concerning variance from fair market value is satisfied.

Is Section 269 of the 2025 Act the replacement for Section 55A?

Section 91 is the direct capital-gains valuation-reference counterpart of old Section 55A. Section 269 contains procedural and broader assessment valuation provisions, and Section 91(2) expressly applies Section 269(3) to (8), with necessary modifications, to a Section 91 reference.

Last reviewed: 28 September 2026. This article is for general legal and tax information. Statutory provisions, rules, notifications and facts of the relevant tax year should be checked before professional reliance.