Skip to content
AapTaxLaw - Indian legal and tax information

Section 273AA and 273B of Income Tax Act 1961: Immunity from Penalty and Reasonable Cause

Sections 273AA and 273B of the Income Tax Act, 1961 deal with two different forms of statutory protection from penalty. Section 273AA concerns immunity from penalty in the special situation of abated settlement proceedings, while Section 273B prevents imposition of penalty for specified failures where the person or assessee proves that there was reasonable cause for the failure.

Applicable-law note: This article explains Sections 273AA and 273B of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for periods governed by that Act. Section 273AA is a legacy provision tied to settlement proceedings under Section 245C that abated under Section 245HA. The relevant assessment year and the version of the statute applicable to that period should always be checked.

Section 273AA - Power to grant immunity from penalty

Section 273AA permits a person to apply to the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner for immunity from penalty where the statutory conditions connected with an abated settlement proceeding are satisfied.

Who could apply under Section 273AA?

Under sub-section (1), the provision applies where both of these conditions exist:

  • the person had made an application for settlement under Section 245C and the settlement proceedings abated under Section 245HA; and
  • penalty proceedings were initiated under the Income Tax Act.

Time for making the application

Section 273AA(2) provides that the application cannot be made after penalty has been imposed following the abatement. The statutory sequence is therefore important: an eligible application for immunity must precede the post-abatement imposition of penalty.

Conditions for grant of immunity

Under Section 273AA(3), the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner may grant immunity from imposition of penalty, subject to conditions considered appropriate, if satisfied that after abatement the person:

  • co-operated with the income-tax authority in the proceedings; and
  • made a full and true disclosure of income and of the manner in which that income was derived.

The use of the word "may" makes the relief discretionary even where the statutory eligibility requirements are present. The authority must consider the statutory conditions and the facts of the case.

Time limit and hearing - Section 273AA(3A)

An order accepting or rejecting the application, wholly or partly, is required to be passed within twelve months from the end of the month in which the application is received by the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner. An application cannot be rejected, wholly or partly, without giving the assessee an opportunity of being heard.

Withdrawal of immunity

Section 273AA contains two routes by which immunity may cease to protect the applicant:

  • under sub-section (4), immunity stands withdrawn if the person fails to comply with a condition subject to which immunity was granted; and
  • under sub-section (5), immunity may be withdrawn if the authority is satisfied that, in proceedings after abatement, the person concealed particulars material to the assessment or gave false evidence.

After withdrawal, the Act applies as if the immunity had not been granted, subject to the terms of the relevant sub-section.

Current relevance: Section 273AA is linked to the former settlement mechanism under Sections 245C and 245HA. It should therefore be read in its historical and transitional setting rather than as a general present-day immunity application for every penalty proceeding.

Section 273B - Penalty not to be imposed where reasonable cause is proved

Section 273B is a protective provision. For failures specifically listed in the section, no penalty is imposable if the person or assessee proves that there was reasonable cause for the failure.

Meaning of reasonable cause

The Act does not give Section 273B a single exhaustive definition of "reasonable cause." In applying the provision, the explanation offered for the particular failure, the surrounding facts and supporting material have to be considered. The statutory burden is on the person or assessee to prove reasonable cause.

Section 273B applies only to specified penalty provisions

Section 273B is not a blanket defence against every penalty under the Income Tax Act. Its protection is confined to failures covered by the provisions expressly listed in Section 273B as applicable for the relevant period. The list has changed through legislative amendments, so the version applicable to the relevant assessment year or date of default must be verified.

Among the provisions historically or presently appearing in Section 273B are specified defaults under Sections 271, 271A, 271AA, 271B, 271BA, 271BB, 271C, 271CA, 271D, 271E, 271F, 271FA, 271FAB, 271FB, 271G, 271GA, 271GB, 271H, 271-I, 271J, 272A, 272AA, 272B, 272BB, 272BBB and specified clauses of Section 273, subject always to the statutory text applicable to the relevant period.

How Section 273B operates

QuestionPosition under Section 273B
Does every technical default automatically attract penalty?No. For a failure covered by Section 273B, penalty is not imposable if reasonable cause for that failure is proved.
Who must establish reasonable cause?The person or assessee seeking the protection must prove it.
Does Section 273B apply to every penalty provision?No. It applies only to provisions expressly covered by the section for the relevant period.
What should be checked first?The exact default, the penalty provision invoked, the applicable statutory version and the evidence supporting the asserted reasonable cause.

Difference between Section 273AA and Section 273B

Section 273AASection 273B
Special immunity provision connected with settlement proceedings that abated under Section 245HA.Reasonable-cause protection against penalty for failures under specifically listed provisions.
Requires an application to the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner and satisfaction of statutory conditions.Operates where the person or assessee proves reasonable cause for the relevant failure.
Immunity may be conditional and can be withdrawn in circumstances specified by the section.Does not grant general immunity; it prevents penalty for the particular covered failure where reasonable cause is established.

Evidence law before Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023

Sections 273AA and 273B are substantive provisions of income-tax law. For matters governed by the general law of evidence before the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 came into force on 1 July 2024, the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 was the general evidence statute, subject to its applicability and to the special provisions and procedures of the Income Tax Act. In a Section 273B claim, documents and surrounding facts supporting the asserted reasonable cause may therefore be important in establishing the factual basis of the defence.

Official references

Practical note: Penalty provisions have been amended repeatedly. Before relying on Section 273AA or Section 273B, verify the statutory text applicable to the relevant assessment year, transaction and date of default.