Sections 255 and 256 of Income Tax Act, 1961: ITAT Procedure and Reference to High Court

Section 255 regulates the constitution, procedure and powers of Benches of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. Section 256 preserves the historical reference procedure for questions of law arising from specified ITAT orders passed before 1 October 1998.

Law period: This article states the legal position immediately before 1 July 2024, when the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 came into force. For this period, the references in Section 255(6) remain to the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam does not itself amend Sections 255 or 256.

Section 255 - Procedure of Appellate Tribunal

Section 255 provides how the powers and functions of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) are exercised. Under Section 255(1), the President constitutes Benches from among the Members of the Tribunal.

Constitution of ITAT Benches

BenchPosition under Section 255
Regular BenchSubject to Section 255(3), a Bench consists of one Judicial Member and one Accountant Member.
Single Member BenchThe President, or another Member authorised by the Central Government, may sit singly in an allotted case where the assessee's total income computed by the Assessing Officer does not exceed Rs. 50 lakh.
Special BenchThe President may constitute a Special Bench of three or more Members for a particular case. At least one must be a Judicial Member and one an Accountant Member.

Difference of opinion between Members

Under Section 255(4), a point is decided according to the majority. If the Members who heard the case are equally divided, they state the point or points of difference. The President refers those points for hearing by one or more other Members, and the point is then decided according to the majority of all Members who heard it, including the Members who originally heard the case.

Power of ITAT to regulate procedure

Section 255(5) authorises the Tribunal, subject to the Income Tax Act, to regulate its own procedure and the procedure of its Benches in matters arising from the exercise of its powers and discharge of its functions, including the places at which Benches hold sittings.

Under Section 255(6), the Tribunal has, for discharge of its functions, the powers vested in income-tax authorities referred to in Section 131. Proceedings before the Tribunal are treated as judicial proceedings for the statutory purposes specified in Section 255(6), and the Tribunal is deemed to be a civil court for the purposes stated there.

Pre-1 July 2024 criminal-law references: Section 255(6), for the period covered here, refers to Sections 193, 228 and 196 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. Its civil-court reference is to Section 195 and the relevant Chapter of the Code of Criminal Procedure; the original statutory wording historically mentioned the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, which had been replaced by the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

Faceless procedure provisions under Section 255

Section 255(7) authorises the Central Government to make a scheme by notification in the Official Gazette for disposal of ITAT appeals to improve efficiency, transparency and accountability. The statutory objectives include reducing interface between the Tribunal and parties to the extent technologically feasible, optimising resources and introducing an appellate system with dynamic jurisdiction.

Section 255(8) permits specified modifications or adaptations for giving effect to such a scheme. By the Finance Act, 2024, the statutory deadline for issuing such directions was extended to 31 March 2025. Section 255(9) requires notifications under these provisions to be laid before each House of Parliament.

Section 256 - Statement of case to the High Court

Section 256 belongs to the older reference jurisdiction. Its operative wording is expressly tied to an order under Section 254 passed before 1 October 1998. It should therefore not be presented as the ordinary route for challenging a current ITAT order.

For an eligible pre-1 October 1998 order, the assessee or the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner may, within 60 days of service of notice of the order, apply in the prescribed form requiring the Tribunal to refer a question of law arising from that order to the High Court. An assessee's application carries a fee of Rs. 200. The Tribunal may allow presentation within a further period not exceeding 30 days if sufficient cause prevented timely filing.

Where the Tribunal refuses to state the case on the ground that no question of law arises, Section 256(2) permits the assessee or the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner to apply to the High Court within six months from service of notice of refusal. Section 256(2A) allows the High Court to admit a delayed application if sufficient cause is shown.

If the Tribunal refuses to state a case which the assessee required it to state, Section 256(3) permits the assessee, within 30 days of receiving notice of refusal, to withdraw the application, in which event the fee is refunded.

High Court appeal for later ITAT orders

For ITAT orders outside the historical Section 256 reference regime, the relevant statutory route is generally an appeal to the High Court under Section 260A, subject to the statutory requirement that the case involves a substantial question of law and the other conditions of that provision.

Related provisions

Sections 253 and 254 deal with appeals to the Tribunal and its orders. Sections 257 and 258 contain connected provisions concerning the historical reference mechanism.

Official references

See the Income Tax Department - Section 255, Income Tax Department - Section 256, the Income Tax e-Filing Portal and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal.

Important: Section 256 is retained because old reference proceedings may still require the historical statutory framework. It should be read with the date restriction built into the section. Current High Court challenges to qualifying ITAT orders proceed under the statutory appellate regime, principally Section 260A.